Discovery 2
Overview
Sold as S, GS, SE, ES and HSE, the Discovery 2 (Series II) carried over Land Rover's classic full-time dual-range 4WD with live axles, coil springs front, and a self-levelling air spring or coil rear. It is genuinely capable off-road and roomy with the optional third row, but it is the vehicle on this list to buy with the most care: the engineering is charming and the electronics fragile. Australian buyers got the five-cylinder 2.5L Td5 turbo-diesel as the mainstay (the one most people want), the 4.0L Bosch-injected 'Thor' V8 petrol, and after the 2003 facelift a 4.6L V8 petrol. The Td5's reputation rests on a handful of well-known faults - the oil-in-loom (oil-in-ECU) wiring issue, early plastic head dowels causing head gasket failure, and the fuel pressure regulator (FPR) leak - all fixable and well documented. The petrol V8s share the Rover aluminium block's dreaded cylinder liner slip. Add ACE active anti-roll, ABS/SLABS modules, and rear air suspension that all age badly, and you have a 4WD that rewards a knowledgeable owner with parts on the shelf and punishes anyone expecting Toyota set-and-forget ownership. Buy on history and condition, not on price.
Engines & variants
2.5L Td5 turbo-diesel
Pros
- Torquey, characterful five-cylinder diesel - good low-down pull off-road
- Far more economical than the thirsty V8 petrols
- Well-documented faults with cheap, known DIY fixes
- Strong UK/Aus aftermarket and specialist support
- Most sought-after and best-resale Discovery 2 engine
Cons
- Will not tolerate overheating - cooling system must be perfect
- Oil-in-loom and head dowel issues are near-universal if unaddressed
- Fuel pressure regulator leak is a common no-start cause
- Turbo runaway risk from cracked fuel rail / injector seals
- Electronics (ECU, sensors) are fragile and dealer-priced new
Known problems
4.0L V8 petrol (Thor)
Pros
- Smooth, torquey V8 with a pleasant exhaust note
- Much cheaper to buy than a good Td5
- Simpler fuelling than the diesel - no oil-in-loom drama
- Responds to LPG conversion to tame fuel cost
Cons
- Cylinder liner slip is the engine's signature killer
- Very thirsty, poor touring range on petrol alone
- Weak resale next to the Td5 diesel
- Aluminium block intolerant of any cooling neglect
Known problems
4.6L V8 petrol (Thor)
Pros
- Stronger and torquier than the 4.0 - the best-performing Disco 2
- Smooth, quiet V8 well-suited to the facelift cars
- Cheap to buy because petrol scares buyers off
- Takes LPG well
Cons
- Shares the same aluminium-block liner-slip risk as the 4.0
- Even thirstier than the 4.0L
- Only on late 2003-2004 facelift cars - low volume in Australia
- Auto-only; weak resale versus the Td5
Known problems